Sadly, but as expected, the Hong Kong police have denied any wrongdoing in their handling of the pro-democracy demonstrations after Amnesty International’s report documenting rampant Hong Kong police brutality.
The evidence leaves little room for doubt—in an apparent thirst for retaliation, Hong Kong’s security forces have engaged in a disturbing pattern of reckless and unlawful tactics against people during the protests.Amnesty International
The Hong Kong police spokesman’s response is incredibly weak. He basically just says that enforcing the law is really hard. (Yeah, no kidding!) He did not respond at all to Amnesty International’s assertions of rampant police brutality. He also complained that the report did not provide identities of the people that Amnesty interviewed during their investigation nor the time and place of the alleged police misconduct, so that the Hong Kong police couldn’t check the facts. To anyone thinking at all clearly, it is obvious that Amnesty would not provide those details; it would just leave those that were interviewed open to retaliation by the police (who have already shown that they will resort to brutal tactics). So, his complaint is just a flaccid attempt at deflecting Amnesty International’s completely on-point criticism of the Hong Kong police and government.
As we mentioned in our post from yesterday, this report was an opportunity for the Hong Kong government to establish an independent investigation of the Hong Kong police, as the protesters demand. The Amnesty International report says that the Hong Kong police cannot be trusted to investigate themselves and also calls for an independent investigation:
Given the pervasiveness of the abuses we found, it is clear that the Hong Kong Police Force is no longer in a position to investigate itself and remedy the widespread unlawful suppression of protesters. Amnesty International is urgently calling for an independent, impartial investigation aimed at delivering prosecutions, justice and reparation, as there is little trust in existing internal mechanisms such as the Independent Police Complaints Commission.Amnesty International
The Hong Kong government and police force have completely lost legitimacy. The Hong Kong police spokesman’s response to the Amnesty International report sounds exactly like “news” articles published by the CCP’s lapdog media outlets when the CCP has done something especially egregious (a nearly daily occurrence) and the international community takes them to task for it. It is all the usual minimizing, deflection, “whataboutism,” and outright lying that we typically see from China Daily, Xinhua News, CCTV, etc. It is sad to see a police force that was once respected throughout Asia and the world come to the point of having lost all credibility, merely another puppet organization whose strings are pulled from Beijing.